We anonymously submitted the discovered errors to IDEs. The following list of bugs is provided for reviewers to check.
It's worth noting that when we submitted bugs to the NetBeans bug repository, the maintainers told us, "These errors are a major issue.
However, if you're not going to submit a pull request to fix them, please stop submitting. Listing problems is not helpful."
Therefore, in our paper, we did not count the bug submissions and confirmations for NetBeans. All the confirmed bugs were from Eclipse and IntelliJ IDEA.
In the subsequent work, we will submit bugs and corresponding pull requests to fix them to NetBeans to resolve these issues.
| Refactoring Types | Eclipse 4.33.0 | NetBeans 25
| IntelliJ 2024.2.4
|
|---|
| bug id | bug status | bug id | bug status | bug id | bug status |
| 1. | MoveField | 1746 | no-assigned | - | Yes | - | - |
| 2. | MoveField | 1745 | no-assigned | - | Yes | - | - |
| 3. | MoveField | 1744 | no-assigned | - | Yes | - | - |
| 4. | PullDownField | 1738 | no-assigned | 8301 | no-assigned | - | - |
| 5. | MoveClass | 1737 | confirmed | - | Yes | - | - |
| 6. | MoveClass | 1743 | no-assigned | - | Yes | - | - |
| 7. | MoveMethod | - | - | - | Yes | 361683 | confirmed |
| 8. | MoveMethod | 1865 | fixed | 8300 | no-assigned | 361686 | confirmed |
| 9. | MoveMethod | 1866 | no-assigned | - | Yes | 361687 | confirmed |
| 10. | MoveMethod | - | - | - | Yes | 361688 | confirmed |
| 11. | MoveMethod | - | - | - | -- | 361689 | confirmed |
| 12. | ExtractMethod | 1757 | fixed | 8305 | no-assigned | 361729 | confirmed |
| 13. | ExtractMethod | 1758 | fixed | - | Yes | 361730 | confirmed |
| 14. | InlineMethod | 1748 | no-assigned | - | Yes | 361732 | confirmed |
| 15. | RenameField | - | - | - | Yes | 361733 | confirmed |
| 16. | PullDownMethod | 1755 | not-supported | - | Yes | 361735 | confirmed |
| 17. | PullDownMethod | 1756 | confirmed | 8306 | no-assigned | 361736 | confirmed |
| 18. | ChangeMethodSignature | 1749 | not-supported | - | Yes | 361738 | confirmed |
| 19. | ChangeMethodSignature | 1750 | fixed | - | Yes | 361739 | confirmed |
| 20. | ChangeMethodSignature | 1751 | fixed | - | Yes | 361740 | confirmed |
| 21. | ChangeMethodSignature | - | - | - | Yes | 361741 | confirmed |
| 22. | PullUpMethod | 1871 | no-assigned | - | Yes | 361742 | confirmed |
| 23. | PullUpMethod | 1870 | no-assigned | - | Yes | 361743 | confirmed |
| 24. | PullUpMethod | 1869 | no-assigned | - | Yes | 361746 | confirmed |
| 25. | PullUpMethod | 1868 | no-assigned | - | Yes | 361747 | confirmed |
| 26. | PullUpMethod | 1867 | no-assigned | - | Yes | 361748 | confirmed |
| 27. | InlineField | - | - | - | Yes | - | - |
| 28. | InlineField | - | - | - | Yes | - | - |